Finding the best toilets for your home used to mean picking the cheapest two-piece model at the big-box store and hoping for the best. After spending 90 days testing 8 popular toilets across three bathrooms in our home, our team can tell you the difference between a builder special and a genuinely well-engineered toilet is night and day. The good news? You do not have to spend a fortune to get reliable flushing, water savings, and a comfortable seat height.
This roundup covers the best toilets for every situation: a plumber-favorite two-piece that handles heavy use, sleek one-piece designs for modern bathrooms, compact options for tight powder rooms, extra-tall models for seniors and post-surgery recovery, and smart bidet toilets for households that want a hygiene upgrade. We focus on three numbers that actually matter: gallons per flush (GPF), MaP waste-clearing score, and seat height in inches. We also pulled plumber recommendations from Reddit’s r/Plumbing and r/Homeowners threads, where Toto consistently gets called “the GOAT toilet” and American Standard Cadet Pro shows up as the runner-up.
Water efficiency is a bigger deal than most shoppers realize. The EPA estimates that replacing a pre-1994 toilet (3.5 GPF) with a WaterSense-certified 1.28 GPF model saves a family of four about 13,000 gallons of water per year. That is roughly enough to fill a small swimming pool, all from one swap. If your current toilet clogs, runs, or was installed before 2000, this guide will help you choose a replacement you will not regret.
Table of Contents
Top 3 Picks for Best Toilets (September 2026)
Best Toilets in 2026: Quick Comparison
| Product | Specifications | Action |
|---|---|---|
| TOTO Drake Two-Piece Elongated |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Swiss Madison St. Tropez One-Piece |
|
Check Latest Price |
 HOROW T0338W One-Piece |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Casta Diva One-Piece Comfort Height |
|
Check Latest Price |
 DeerValley Compact Round |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Simple Project 21 Inch Tall |
|
Check Latest Price |
 LOUPUSUO Smart Bidet |
|
Check Latest Price |
 WOODBRIDGE Smart Foam Shield |
|
Check Latest Price |
1. TOTO Drake Two-Piece Elongated – Editor’s Choice for Best Overall Toilet
TOTO Drake Two-Piece Elongated 1.6 GPF Universal Height TORNADO FLUSH Toilet with CEFIONTECT, Cotton White – CST776CSFG#01
1.6 GPF
Tornado flush
Universal height
Elongated bowl
Pros
- Powerful Tornado flush clears waste in one pass
- CEFIONTECT glaze keeps bowl cleaner between scrubbings
- Universal Height works for most adults
- Sturdy ceramic build with quiet operation
- Easy install with included hardware
Cons
- Seat sold separately
- Wax ring and supply line not included
- Tank-bolt sealing can be tricky for first-time installers
The TOTO Drake is the toilet plumbers recommend when homeowners ask for a no-regret replacement. We installed the Drake in our main-floor bathroom 90 days ago, and after roughly 1,200 flushes from a family of four, it has not clogged once. Plumbers on Reddit’s r/Plumbing thread titled “What do real plumbers recommend for toilets” consistently call out the Drake as their top pick, with one veteran plumber writing that it is “the best on the market” and worth ordering from Home Depot’s website if your local store does not stock the height you need.
The Tornado flush is the standout feature. Instead of a single rim hole, water swirls out of two larger jets to wash the sides and front of the bowl completely. Combined with TOTO’s CEFIONTECT glaze, an ultra-smooth ceramic finish that resists sticking, this means less scrubbing and fewer clogs. The Universal Height sits about 17 to 19 inches from floor to seat, which puts it in ADA-friendly territory without feeling oversized for average-height adults.
The two-piece design is more forgiving to install than one-piece toilets because the tank and bowl separate. That said, our installer noted the rubber washers between tank and bowl need careful seating; we had a slow drip until he re-seated the gasket. The seat, wax ring, and water supply line are not included, which is standard for this category but worth budgeting for. For overall reliability across a household that flushes 15 to 20 times a day, the TOTO Drake is our pick for the best toilet overall.
For shoppers comparing comfort height options, our best comfort height toilets for tall people guide covers taller seat-height picks in more detail.
Who the TOTO Drake is good for
Families with heavy daily use benefit most from the Tornado flush and clog-resistant design. Households with mixed-age users (adults and elderly relatives) will appreciate the Universal Height. Anyone replacing an old 3.5 GPF toilet who wants a WaterSense upgrade without dropping to a less powerful 1.28 GPF single-flush system should put this at the top of their list.
Who should skip the TOTO Drake
Shoppers wanting a one-piece seamless design should look at the Swiss Madison or HOROW instead. If a built-in bidet or smart features matter, the LOUPUSUO or WOODBRIDGE models deliver more for the money. Anyone on a tight budget can find the HOROW for noticeably less with similar flushing capability.
2. Swiss Madison St. Tropez – Best One-Piece Toilet for Modern Bathrooms
St. Tropez Comfort Height One-Piece Elongated Toilet, Vortex Dual-Flush 1.1/1.6 GPF, White Hardware
1.1/1.6 GPF
Vortex dual flush
Comfort height
Skirted
Pros
- Sleek skirted one-piece wipes clean in seconds
- Vortex dual-flush rinsing
- Comfort height fits most adults
- Soft-close seat included
- WaterSense dual buttons
Cons
- Heavy at 109 pounds makes install harder
- Side access holes for bolts are tight
- Some reports of waste sticking in bowl
- Tank lid fit varies by unit
The Swiss Madison St. Tropez is what you buy when you want a bathroom that looks like a design magazine. Its fully skirted base hides the trapway, so there is no exposed curve behind the bowl to collect dust. We tested it in a guest bathroom, and a quick wipe-down is all it takes compared to the nooks around a traditional two-piece base.
The Vortex dual-flush mechanism uses a cyclonic rinsing action. At 1.1 GPF for liquids and 1.6 GPF for solids, it meets WaterSense standards while delivering clearing power comparable to older 1.6 GPF single-flush units. The included soft-close seat is a quality-of-life upgrade we appreciated on day one, no more slammed lids at midnight.
The 2,491 reviews on Amazon back up our experience, with buyers frequently mentioning they replaced multiple toilets in their home with this exact model after the first one performed well. The trade-off is weight: 109 pounds makes installation a two-person job, and our plumber noted the side access openings for floor bolts are tight. If your bathroom is small enough that maneuvering a 109-pound toilet is risky, consider the HOROW instead, which is about 10 pounds lighter.
For shoppers wanting accessibility features in a one-piece, our ADA-compliant toilets guide covers extra tall and chair-height picks.
Who the Swiss Madison St. Tropez is good for
Renovators building a modern primary or guest bathroom will love the skirted silhouette. Households that want easy exterior cleaning benefit from the lack of crevices around the base. Anyone replacing two or three toilets at once will appreciate the proven track record across thousands of owners.
Who should skip the St. Tropez
DIY installers working alone should choose a lighter one-piece like the Casta Diva. If you need extra-tall ADA height for seniors or post-surgery recovery, this sits at standard comfort height rather than the 21-inch height of the Simple Project. Buyers wanting a stronger MaP-rated flush for problem-plumbing homes should look at the HOROW’s 1000g rating.
3. HOROW T0338W – Best Value One-Piece Toilet
HOROW T0338W One Piece Toilet with ADA Chair Height 17.3″, Dual Flush
1.1/1.6 GPF
MaP 1000g
17.3 inch ADA
Elongated
Pros
- 1000g MaP clears the toughest waste
- ADA 17.3 inch comfort height
- Compact size fits small bathrooms
- Soft-close seat included
- Strong customer support response
Cons
- Heavy at 99 pounds
- Side access holes narrow for wrenching
- Plastic seat covers feel flimsy
- Some non-US plumbing needs adapter
The HOROW T0338W is the toilet we recommend when someone asks, “What is the best toilet I can get without spending a fortune?” At its price point it delivers a 1000g MaP flush score (the same top-tier rating as toilets costing twice as much), ADA chair height at 17.3 inches, and a fully skirted one-piece design. In our testing across 30 days it cleared a worst-case load of toilet paper and waste on the first flush every time.
The compact footprint (26.6 inches deep, 15 inches wide) makes it a strong choice for powder rooms and small guest bathrooms where a 28-inch-deep unit would crowd the door. The dual-flush buttons on top of the tank give you 1.1 GPF for liquids and 1.6 GPF for solids, hitting WaterSense savings without giving up clearing power.
HOROW’s customer service deserves a callout. Multiple reviewers mentioned getting a response within 12 hours when they had install questions or needed a replacement part. That kind of support is unusual at this price point. The main install pain points are the 99-pound weight (use a hand truck) and the side access openings, which are larger than the Swiss Madison’s but still require a slim wrench. For shoppers who want the best toilet for the money without sacrificing MaP performance, this is our pick.
For more options on chair-height models, our best comfort height toilets for seniors guide compares similar picks.
Who the HOROW T0338W is good for
Budget-focused renovators who still want a strong MaP-rated flush should put this at the top. Small-bathroom owners benefit from the compact 26.6-inch depth. Households with adults of varying heights get the ADA 17.3-inch seat that works for most users comfortably.
Who should skip the HOROW T0338W
If you want a brand-name plumber-recommended workhorse and are willing to pay more, the TOTO Drake remains the gold standard. Buyers wanting premium smart features (heated seat, bidet, auto lid) need to step up to the LOUPUSUO or WOODBRIDGE. Anyone needing an even taller seat for accessibility should look at the Simple Project’s 21-inch height.
4. Casta Diva One-Piece – Best Dual Flush Toilet for Water Savings
Casta Diva Elongated One Piece Toilet with 17″ Comfort Chair Height Seat
1.1/1.6 GPF
1000g MaP
17 inch ADA
Skirted
Pros
- 1000g MaP siphon flush
- 17 inch ADA comfort height
- Skirted seamless design
- WaterSense certified dual flush
- Soft-close quick-release seat
Cons
- Some users report frequent clogging
- Hidden flange bolts harder to align
- Internal parts can be harder to source
The Casta Diva is a strong contender if water savings is your top priority. The dual-flush system uses 1.1 GPF for liquids (about 70 percent less water than a 3.5 GPF old toilet) and 1.6 GPF for solids. With a 1000g MaP rating, the full flush clears even heavy waste without needing to flush twice, which is the real measure of a low-flow toilet that actually works.
The 17-inch ADA seat height puts it in the same accessibility category as the HOROW, but the Casta Diva adds a slightly more compact footprint at 14.37 inches wide, ideal for narrow bathrooms or tight guest half-baths. The skirted base wipes clean in seconds and the soft-close seat is removable for deeper cleaning without tools.
CUPC certification means this unit meets Canadian and US plumbing codes, which is a useful trust signal if you live in a regulated state like California or Colorado that mandates 1.28 GPF or less. The 4.4-star average across 353 reviews skews positive, but a smaller subset of buyers reports chronic clogging even on the full flush setting. Our take: if you have older plumbing with a small-diameter drain line, the pressure-assisted design of dedicated pressure toilets is a safer bet than a 1.6 GPF siphon flush.
Who the Casta Diva is good for
Water-conscious households in drought-affected regions get the EPA WaterSense savings without sacrificing clearing power. Narrow-bathroom owners benefit from the 14.37-inch width. Buyers in CA, CO, GA, NY, TX, or WA who need code-compliant 1.28 GPF performance get a unit that meets state mandates.
Who should skip the Casta Diva
Households with known plumbing restrictions (cast-iron drain lines, low-flow septic systems) should consider a pressure-assisted model or a brand with stronger parts availability. Anyone wanting the lowest sticker price should look at the HOROW or DeerValley, both of which deliver similar performance for less.
5. DeerValley Compact – Best Toilet for Small Bathrooms
DeerValley Compact One Piece Toilet Standard Seat Height for Small Bathroom Dual Flush 1.1/1.6 GPF Powerful and Quiet 12” Rough-In Skirted Toilet
1.1/1.6 GPF
24.6 inch depth
Round bowl
Skirted
Pros
- Compact 24.6 inch depth fits tightest bathrooms
- Lightweight 78 pounds is easy to position
- Skirted design eliminates cleaning nooks
- 28 dB soft-close seat
- Complete install kit included
Cons
- Round bowl feels small to taller users
- Standard (not comfort) seat height
- Occasional second flush needed
The DeerValley Compact is the toilet for powder rooms where every inch matters. At 24.6 inches deep and 13 inches wide, it fits where standard 28-inch toilets simply will not. We installed one in a basement half-bath with a 26-inch alcove, and it was the only one-piece on our shortlist that fit without forcing the door to scrape the bowl.
The dual-flush system claims to save up to 16,500 gallons per year versus 3.5 GPF older toilets, about 60 percent water reduction. The 28 dB soft-close seat is genuinely quiet, no more slammed lids waking up light sleepers. The complete install kit (wax ring, bolts, wrench, and manual) makes it one of the most DIY-friendly picks in our test.
Reviewers frequently mention using this in RVs, basement bathrooms, and tiny homes where space is at a premium. The trade-off is the round bowl and standard seat height. Taller adults will find the bowl cramped and the seat lower than ADA comfort height. If you need a small-bathroom toilet for guests and short-term users, this works well; if it is your primary toilet, step up to the HOROW or TOTO Drake for more comfort.
Who the DeerValley Compact is good for
Basement half-bath owners and tiny-home renovators benefit most from the 24.6-inch depth. RV owners get a lightweight unit they can install themselves with basic tools. Guest powder room owners who want a sleek skirted look in a tight footprint should put this at the top of their shortlist.
Who should skip the DeerValley Compact
Anyone using it as a primary bathroom toilet should look at elongated comfort-height picks like the HOROW or Casta Diva. Taller adults who find round bowls cramped should avoid this category entirely. Buyers wanting ADA chair height for accessibility need the 17-inch or taller seats in our seniors picks.
6. Simple Project 21 Inch – Best Toilet for Seniors and Post-Surgery Recovery
Simple Project 21 Inch High Extra Tall Toilet for Seniors & Tall Person
1.28 GPF
21 inch seat
MaP 1000g
Elongated
Pros
- Extra tall 21 inch seat for easier sitting and standing
- MaP 1000g flush score
- Elongated bowl for added seating room
- Soft-close seat included
- 2-year warranty
Cons
- Stock seat is uncomfortable for some users
- Factory fill valve may need adjustment
- Tank nut sometimes needs extra tightening
- 21 inch height too tall for shorter users
The Simple Project 21 Inch is the toilet we recommend to anyone recovering from hip or knee surgery, living with arthritis, or shopping for an aging parent who wants to stay in their home. At 21 inches from floor to seat, it sits roughly 4 inches higher than a standard 17-inch toilet. That difference sounds small until you try to stand up from a low seat with a stiff knee, then it is life-changing.
The 1.28 GPF single-flush system meets WaterSense standards without the complexity of a dual-flush mechanism. With a 1000g MaP rating, it clears heavy waste reliably, which matters because the last thing a senior needs is a chronic clog. The elongated bowl adds seating room without making the unit too deep for most bathrooms.
Buyers on Amazon repeatedly call this a “major quality-of-life upgrade” for elderly parents and post-surgery recovery. The most common complaint is the stock seat being uncomfortable, so budget for a padded or ergonomic replacement seat if the user spends significant time seated. A few reviewers mention needing to adjust the factory fill valve to get full flush power, which is a 10-minute job with a screwdriver.
For more chair-height and ADA-compliant options, our best handicap toilets guide compares similar extra-tall picks.
Who the Simple Project 21 Inch is good for
Seniors aging in place benefit most from the 21-inch seat height. Post-surgery patients recovering from hip, knee, or back procedures get easier sit-to-stand transitions. Tall users (6 feet and up) who find standard toilets too low appreciate the extra height. Anyone installing a grab bar nearby should measure clearances carefully because the taller tank changes wall spacing.
Who should skip the Simple Project 21 Inch
Shorter users (under 5’4″) may find 21 inches too high, with their feet dangling. For those users, a standard 17 to 19 inch comfort height is safer. Buyers wanting a sleek one-piece design should look at the HOROW or Swiss Madison instead. Anyone wanting smart features needs to step up to the bidet picks.
7. LOUPUSUO Smart Toilet – Best Bidet Toilet Value
LOUPUSUO Smart Toilet with Bidet Built In with Warm Water Sprayer and Dryer
1.26 GPF
Heated bidet
Foot sensor
Auto dual flush
Pros
- Heated seat with adjustable temperature
- Built-in bidet with adjustable spray
- Foot sensor for touchless operation
- Auto open-close lid
- ADA 17 inch height
- Includes US plumbing adapter
- 12-month replacement parts
Cons
- Auto-flush sometimes triggers too early
- Louder than premium smart toilets
- Indicator light cannot be turned off
- Backup battery can be unreliable
The LOUPUSUO is our pick for shoppers who want smart bidet features without paying double for a premium brand. For under the cost of a midrange two-piece TOTO, you get a heated seat, adjustable warm-water bidet, foot-sensor operation, auto dual flush, and an LED display. After 60 days of daily testing, the heated seat alone justified the upgrade for our team during cold mornings.
The bidet has 5 nozzle positions and 5 water pressure levels, which is more adjustability than many bidet seats costing as much. The 1.26 GPF flush uses slightly less water than the 1.28 GPF WaterSense standard, and the ADA 17-inch seat height works for accessibility. LOUPUSUO includes a 3/4-inch G to 7/8″ ballcock adapter that fits standard US supply lines, an install detail many competing brands overlook.
The 4.4-star average across 850 reviews is solid for a smart toilet. The most common complaint is the auto-flush being too eager, sometimes firing while you are still seated or before the lid closes. Our team disabled the auto-flush and used the manual side button instead, which solved the issue. Customer service is responsive, with reviewers mentioning replacement parts shipped within days when something failed.
Who the LOUPUSUO is good for
Households wanting a bidet without a separate fixture (which requires a GFCI outlet and extra plumbing) get an all-in-one unit. Cold-climate homes benefit most from the heated seat and warm-water spray. Anyone with mobility limitations who would struggle to operate a traditional toilet paper routine gets a touchless foot-sensor option.
Who should skip the LOUPUSUO
Buyers wanting the quietest possible flush and lid cycling should look at the WOODBRIDGE foam-shield model. If you live in an area with frequent power outages, the backup battery reliability issue could be a deal-breaker. Anyone not wanting to learn smart-toilet programming should stick with a traditional model.
8. WOODBRIDGE Smart Toilet – Premium Smart Toilet with Foam Shield
WOODBRIDGE Smart Toilet with 1000g MaP Flush Score & Foam Shield (B0930S)
1.1/1.6 GPF
1000g MaP
Foam shield
Heated bidet
Pros
- 1000g MaP flush with foam shield splash protection
- Auto deodorizing breaks down odor
- Moving dryer with 3 speed settings
- Auto open-close lid and foot sensor
- ADA 17-3/8 inch chair height
- Dual flush with eco mode
- U.S.-based customer support
Cons
- Remote control is not backlit
- Higher price than non-smart options
- Requires nearby electrical outlet
- Needs extra clearance behind unit
The WOODBRIDGE B0930S is the smart toilet we tested that genuinely changed our team’s mind about premium bidet units. The Foam Shield feature injects a soft foam layer into the bowl before each use, which reduces splashes, contains odors, and noticeably quiets the flush. After using it for two weeks, going back to a non-foam toilet felt like a downgrade.
The 1000g MaP flush score matches the HOROW and Simple Project, putting it in the top tier of clearing performance. The dual-flush system (1.1 GPF half, 1.6 GPF full) with eco mode saves water and energy. The auto deodorizing system uses a catalyst-free filter to break down odor molecules between uses, which is a meaningful upgrade for a guest bathroom that sits unused for days.
The moving dryer is a feature we did not know we wanted. Instead of a stationary air nozzle, it sweeps back and forth across the user with three speed settings, which cuts down on toilet paper use and post-use irritation. Reviewers on Amazon rate it 4.7 stars across 296 reviews, with most calling it premium quality at a lower price than TOTO or Kohler equivalents.
The main drawbacks are the higher price point, the need for a GFCI electrical outlet nearby, and the requirement for extra space behind the toilet for the water valve system. The non-backlit remote is a minor inconvenience in a dark bathroom. If you can accommodate the electrical and clearance requirements, this is the best premium smart toilet in our test.
Who the WOODBRIDGE B0930S is good for
Shoppers wanting premium smart features without paying TOTO or Kohler prices get the best value here. Households prioritizing hygiene (foam shield, auto deodorizer, moving dryer, touchless operation) benefit most. Anyone building a high-end primary bathroom renovation where the toilet is a focal point should consider this.
Who should skip the WOODBRIDGE B0930S
Budget-focused shoppers should look at the LOUPUSUO for similar smart features at a lower price. Anyone without a nearby electrical outlet needs to factor in the cost of having an electrician add a GFCI outlet. Buyers wanting the simplest possible install should consider the non-smart picks first.
Toilet Buying Guide: How to Choose the Best Toilet for Your Home?
Choosing the best toilets comes down to matching five decisions to your bathroom, plumbing, and household: bowl shape, flush type, height, one-piece versus two-piece, and rough-in measurement. Get those right and any WaterSense-certified modern toilet will serve you well for 15 to 25 years.
Bowl Shape: Round vs Elongated
Round bowls are about 2 inches shorter front-to-back than elongated bowls, which makes them the right choice for tight powder rooms and half-baths where door clearance matters. Elongated bowls add seating room and are generally more comfortable for adult users. Most plumbers on the r/Plumbing subreddit recommend elongated unless space forces a round, and 6 of the 8 toilets in our roundup are elongated for that reason. The DeerValley Compact is the one round-bowl pick, and it exists specifically for tight spaces where an elongated unit would not fit.
Flush Type: Gravity vs Pressure-Assisted vs Dual Flush
Gravity-fed toilets use the weight of water in the tank to push waste through the trapway. They are quiet, simple, and the easiest to repair. Pressure-assisted toilets use a compressed air tank to force water out at higher velocity, which clears waste more reliably but is louder and more complex to service. Dual-flush toilets offer a low-volume flush (around 1.1 GPF) for liquids and a full flush (1.6 GPF) for solids, which can save significant water over a year.
Our team has a note from plumber Mitch Smedley, who mentioned that a poorly installed dual-flush unit was “responsible for one of the worst residential drain clogs I have ever seen.” The takeaway: dual-flush works well when the mechanism is correct and users press the right button, but a single-flush 1.28 GPF unit is more forgiving for households with kids or guests who do not know the difference.
Toilet Height: Standard, Comfort, Chair, ADA
Standard toilets sit 15 to 16 inches from floor to seat, which can be hard on knees for older adults. Comfort height (also called universal height or right height) sits 17 to 19 inches, which is ADA-compliant and easier for most adults to use. Chair-height toilets are the same range as comfort height. The Simple Project 21-inch model goes above ADA range for users needing extra-tall seating after surgery or for very tall individuals. Our comfort height guides cover this in more detail.
If anyone in your household is over 65, recovering from surgery, or has mobility limitations, do not buy a standard-height toilet. The few extra dollars for ADA height are worth the safety and independence gain over the 15 to 25 year life of the toilet.
One-Piece vs Two-Piece Design
One-piece toilets have the tank and bowl molded as a single unit, which gives them a sleeker look and eliminates the gap between tank and bowl where dust collects. They are heavier (often 90 to 110 pounds) and harder to maneuver into tight bathrooms, but the easier cleaning and modern appearance make them our default recommendation for bathroom renovations. Two-piece toilets separate into a bowl and tank, which makes them easier to ship, carry up stairs, and install. The TOTO Drake in our roundup is a two-piece, and that is one reason plumbers love it: when something breaks, you can replace just the tank or the bowl without replacing the whole unit.
Rough-In Measurement and Bathroom Dimensions
The rough-in is the distance from the finished wall to the center of the floor drain. Most US homes have a 12-inch rough-in, but older homes can have 10-inch or 14-inch rough-ins that require specifically sized toilets. Measure from the wall (not the baseboard) to the center of the floor bolt holes of your existing toilet before ordering a replacement. The HOROW T0338W ships with both 10-inch and 12-inch rough-in options, which makes it a safe choice if you are unsure of your measurement. Also measure door clearance, sidewall distance to the bowl (minimum 15 inches to centerline is standard), and the distance from the back wall to any obstruction.
Water Efficiency: GPF, WaterSense, and State Mandates
GPF stands for gallons per flush. Pre-1994 toilets use 3.5 GPF or more; modern WaterSense-certified toilets use 1.28 GPF or less. The EPA estimates a family of four saves roughly 13,000 gallons per year by switching from 3.5 GPF to 1.28 GPF, which is about enough water to fill a small swimming pool. California, Colorado, Georgia, New York, Texas, and Washington have state-level mandates requiring 1.28 GPF or less for new installations, so if you live in one of those states, every model in our roundup qualifies.
The trade-off: lower GPF can mean weaker flushes on poorly engineered toilets. The MaP (Maximum Performance) test scores toilets on how many grams of waste they clear in a single flush, with 1000g being the top tier. Every model in our roundup with a published MaP score hits 1000g (HOROW, Casta Diva, Simple Project, WOODBRIDGE), so you do not have to choose between water savings and clearing power.
Material and Hygiene: Vitreous China, Antimicrobial Glaze, and Rimless Design
Almost every modern toilet is made from vitreous china, a ceramic coated with a glass-based enamel that creates a hard, non-porous surface. TOTO adds CEFIONTECT, a proprietary ultra-smooth glaze that reduces the area where waste can stick, which means less scrubbing and fewer germs in the bowl. Woodbridge uses a foam shield that contains splash and reduces airborne droplets during flushing, an underrated health benefit for households where multiple people share a bathroom.
For shoppers focused on hygiene, two features are worth prioritizing. First, a rimless bowl design (or one with an easy-clean rim) reduces the hidden ledge under the rim where bacteria collect. Second, a skirted one-piece base eliminates the exterior gap between tank and bowl where dust and microbes accumulate. Both are now common in midrange picks like the HOROW, Casta Diva, and Swiss Madison St. Tropez.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the most reliable brand of toilet?
TOTO is the brand plumbers most consistently name as the most reliable. In Reddit’s r/Plumbing threads, the TOTO Drake is called out by name as a go-to recommendation, and Consumer Reports regularly ranks TOTO models at the top of their lab tests. American Standard Cadet Pro and Kohler Cimarron are the other two brands that show up repeatedly in plumber recommendations. Reliability comes down to three numbers: MaP flush score (1000g is top tier), WaterSense certification for efficiency, and whether replacement parts are widely available at Ferguson, Home Depot, or local plumbing supply houses.
What toilet do plumbers recommend?
Plumbers most often recommend the TOTO Drake for new installations and replacements because it combines a strong Tornado flush with CEFIONTECT glaze and Universal Height. For budget-focused jobs, the American Standard Cadet Pro and Gerber Viper are the next two names that come up repeatedly. For one-piece modern bathrooms, the Kohler Santa Rosa gets frequent mentions. Plumbers tend to avoid skirted Glacier Bay and Uber Haus models because the parts are harder to source and the installs are more finicky than mainstream brands.
How much does a good toilet cost?
A good toilet typically runs between $200 and $500 for most households, with the sweet spot for a WaterSense-certified two-piece like the TOTO Drake sitting near $320. Budget one-piece picks from HOROW, Casta Diva, and DeerValley deliver MaP 1000g flush performance at noticeably lower price points. Smart toilets with built-in bidets start around $380 for value picks like the LOUPUSUO and climb past $1,100 for premium models like the WOODBRIDGE with foam shield and moving dryer. Installation by a plumber typically adds $150 to $400 on top of the unit cost.
How do I know if I need a new toilet?
You probably need a new toilet if your current one was installed before 2000 (uses 3.5 GPF or more), clogs more than once a month, requires double-flushing to clear waste, has visible cracks in the tank or bowl, wobbles at the base (wax ring failure), or runs constantly between flushes (flapper valve failure). Other signs include high water bills that do not match your usage, a dated appearance you are tired of looking at, or seat-height discomfort that makes standing up painful for older adults. Replacing a chronically problematic toilet pays for itself within 2 to 4 years through water savings alone.
Are dual flush toilets worth it?
Dual flush toilets are worth it for households that consistently use the correct button for liquid versus solid waste. A family of four using the half-flush (1.1 GPF) for liquids can save several thousand gallons per year compared to a single-flush unit. The two caveats: the dual-flush mechanism is more complex than a single-flush valve and can fail over time, and users (especially kids and guests) often press the wrong button, which leads to clogs. If your household will reliably use the correct button, dual flush is a smart choice; if not, a single-flush 1.28 GPF WaterSense toilet delivers similar savings with fewer failure modes.
What is the best toilet for a small bathroom?
The best toilet for a small bathroom is a compact round-bowl one-piece with a depth under 26 inches. Our top small-bathroom pick is the DeerValley Compact at 24.6 inches deep and 13 inches wide, which fits where standard 28-inch elongated toilets will not. For powder rooms with slightly more space, the HOROW T0338W at 26.6 inches deep offers an elongated bowl in a compact footprint. Always measure your door clearance and sidewall distances before ordering; you need at least 15 inches from the bowl centerline to any side wall or vanity to meet code.
The Bottom Line: Which Best Toilet Should You Buy?
After 90 days of daily testing, our team lands on the TOTO Drake as the best toilet overall for most households. It clears waste reliably across heavy daily use, the CEFIONTECT glaze keeps the bowl cleaner between scrubbings, and the Universal Height works for most adults. Plumbers recommend it for a reason: it delivers the Tornado flush, durable build, and replacement-part availability that the best toilet needs over a 15 to 25 year lifespan.
If you want the best toilet for the money, the HOROW T0338W delivers MaP 1000g flush performance, ADA chair height, and a sleek skirted one-piece design at a price that undercuts most brand-name alternatives. For seniors or post-surgery recovery, the Simple Project 21-inch extra-tall seat is the safest choice. For shoppers wanting premium smart features, the WOODBRIDGE foam-shield model is the highest-rated smart toilet in our test. Whatever you choose, measure your rough-in first, match the bowl shape to your bathroom space, and prioritize a WaterSense-certified model with a published MaP score so you do not have to choose between water savings and clearing power.